Apply Tax per Ship to State - Herbalife

[HQ Secure]

I'm told Herbalife collects tax no matter what state their product is shipped to. Therefore I need to setup my shop to determine what state the product is being shipped to and collect the appropriate taxt for that state. While I've had success in the past setting up one state to collect tax in for some reason when I put in an additional tax zone with it's own tax rate my shop collects double tax. Check this out. Notice how Colorado and Alabama are both being collected and combined into one big tax:

 

Here are my Tax Zones - I added the contribution to divide Florida into it's counties with their specific tax rates and that was working. But when I add Alabama, Colorado, things fall apart.

 

Here are my Tax Rates

 

I had a dream last night that somebody had a shop that also had to collect tax for more than one state. I'm hopping it comes true and I can get some help straightening this out.

 

Seriously, some help would be greatly appreciated.